The same person as 5856? Dates and proximity suggest so, but why the resignation of a rectory for a curacy?
MI Brough: In Memory of Reverend James Fenton, Curate of Stainmore whose Stri . . . and Piety made his death full of Hope and Comfort . . . himself but Afflicting his Friends. And Te . . . publick Loss . . . Dec . . . 1780 aetat 56. (James Fenton buried 5 December 1780. Parish Register )